Unguilded (and NPC's)

~ OOC forums for the Guilds version of the Classic game.
Please be courteous while posting and observe the forum rules.

Moderators: Staff, Game Staff

User avatar
Darnivan
Traveler
Posts: 153
Joined: Fri Dec 07, 2012 6:55 am

Re: Unguilded (and NPC's)

Post by Darnivan » Tue Feb 19, 2013 10:11 pm

There should be a bit more openness as to those rules for people coming back and new people joining the game. When guilds was announced as coming back I made a conquest game to play around a bit and spend most of my turns building and got to a point I was starting to run a little low on turn to war so I tried to find a target, but the only targets were NPC's massively larger than me or one a little over 10% smaller. I tried to declare on the smaller one as the only one I could hope to break but the game wouldn't allow me and gave me no indication as to what the specific rules were or how to find them so I gave up and just spent all my turns building to see how big I could get that way alone.

Maybe put a link on the war page to tell new players what the downhit rules are. As it is this is a very confusing hidden mechanic for new/returning players.

Calen
Lost Soul
Posts: 49
Joined: Sat Oct 31, 2009 12:54 am

Re: Unguilded (and NPC's)

Post by Calen » Tue Feb 19, 2013 10:36 pm

Might I offer a few suggestions?

Let NPCs be treated differently in the function to see if they're hittable. You're not going to piss of a NPC and have them rage quit because a larger kingdom trashed them. Would just need to add one more check to the attack function

1. Does target have at least 90% of your land? - Yes = can declare
2. Has target recently attacked? - Yes = can declare
3. Does target have more networth than you? - Yes = can declare
4. Is the target a NPC? - Yes = can declare

Secondly, in the scrolls have a way to signify that the above checks were complete and you can declare war on those targets. Maybe just a little flag beside their name or something like that. It would be easier for newbies to be able to go to the scrolls and say 'hey, I can declare war on that kingdom!' and not try to figure out on their own what's target-able and whats not.
“If you call one wolf, you invite the pack”
Silver Wolves

User avatar
Kaz
Administrator
Posts: 2614
Joined: Thu Sep 24, 2009 1:27 am
Location: The Vinyards of Fernabergia
Tempers Ball Posts: 3873
Tempers Ball/Braggarts Hall Alt: Kaz
Contact:

Re: Unguilded (and NPC's)

Post by Kaz » Wed Feb 20, 2013 5:11 pm

Darnivan, you're right, there should be a list of these sort of things.

The problem is that there is so much to do that one person - me - struggles to find the time to do everything that might be nice. Things start to build up, and some things end up going undone because the thread they were suggested in fills up with spam, or the PM they were sent in gets hidden under hundreds of other PM's.

The other problem is that so many of these 'new' features are not really all that new. The 'downhits' option was developed for the Solo game at Evernight about 6 or 7 years ago. It's very hard for someone like me who knows all the features, to work out which features are hard to understand for a new or returning player.

You'd be surprised at how few people actually provide feedback on things that are confusing. Sometimes even bugs go unreported for months at a time, even if there is a feedback thread specifically covering the implementation that introduced the glitch. The players that occasionally help test things in the development system, tend to be vets who also have known about the little modifications so long, that they forget that they are 'new' to some people.

We created a wiki in the hope that a few players would be interested in filling it out and making it a useful resource. Unfortunately it seems that we don't really have any wiki-minded community members any more.

If you're interested, maybe you could help provide a line of developmental testing and feedback, that we don't really have access to. PM me if you'd like to help out in any way. Be it putting together a list of things that you found confusing, or testing new features in the development environment.






Calen, the idea of adding some form of notification to the scrolls is something I'm pondering. I think it's likely to be added to the development environment that'll be going live next age.

The freedom to declare on any NPC is something that has been in place previously, but was removed by request.

The ability to downhit on any NPC makes it possible for kingdoms at the top of the scrolls to constantly grow using the NPC's that would ideally be attacked by the lower ranked players trying to reach them. In a classic style game (e.g. Domination, Guilds etc) this causes a small amount of imbalance, however in the Massacre style games like Conquest the combination with getting turns from bounties can essentially give players infinite turns.

This ability was essentially offered up when asking for opinions on whether to put NPC's into guilds. A guild could then have declared on an NPC guild and gained the ability to hit any NPC in the guild. Most people who posted in the thread didn't want that feature for one reason or another.

I think maybe it's worth posting a new copy of the thread for next ages settings. See if we get a few more responses.
Programming is 10% science, 25% ingenuity and 65% getting the ingenuity to work with the science
Wars of Tonan (Monarchy Inspired Miniatures)
Armatures for Sculpting Miniatures

Post Reply

Return to “Guilds”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests